There is another new post below this one too.
Well, it's almost report card time again. I've been talking to Girl2's resource teacher "C" about the new grading system that we are a "trail" school for. It's very, very frustrating. Tonight I decided to send her an email. It took me forever to work up the nerve to hit "send". Here it is:
OK C, I've given this whole report card thing a lot of thought. I can't sleep thinking about it so I thought I'd type it up in an email so I don't forget what I want to say (& maybe I'll be able to sleep some).
If Girl2 is being given failing grades, does this mean that her IEP & the services she receives are not adequate? It would appear that the accommodations are not working or are not adequate if she's failing her classes. On this grading scale a 1 is a failing grade. (I KNOW all the work you & the staff do with Girl2 & we DO appreciate it but with this grading system none of it shows). And for the record WE do not feel she is failing. We know she's making progress but it does not show on her report cards. This grading system shows our daughter IS failing despite the progress she's making.
Girl2 has worked her tail off getting her 50 point AR pin but she still gets a 1 in reading? No, she's not reading by herself at grade level but that's not possible. She's doing the best she can. To the best of her ability. So does this not deserve a higher grade? I know AR is not a part of the grading system but it does show a TON of effort on Girl2's part. Especially since all books she reads are only worth a half point. And she is passing the tests meaning she's comprehending what is being read to her. Actually she now has quite a few sight words. This is progress for Girl2 but is shown as failing on her report card.
This grading system is horrible for self-esteem. No matter how hard Girl2 tries, she will fail. It is giving her an unreachable goal. How is this at all fair?? What kind of incentive is that? "Try your best but no matter what you do, you will FAIL" is what is being taught with this grading system. I have a hard time seeing a way to keep Girl2 motivated to even try when she will fail no matter how much effort she puts in. Yes, we are very proud of her work & tell her that. We use lots & lots of praise for Girl2 but she knows what's on her report card. She knows what other kids (her peers & sister) are getting for grades (kids talk). She's very quick to pick up on these things.
I know it's not YOU, C. You do wonderful work with Girl2. But the system needs to be changed. Hubby & I really, really appreciate all you (& the rest of the staff) do for Girl2. I'm sure you understand our frustration with this whole grading system. I'm sure it's frustrating for you too! I just wanted to give you my two cents (well, maybe a bit more) on this issue. Thanks, Mom22girls
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment